Why did the restore fail on the log shipped secondary database

I was doing some random testing for a different log shipping related scenario, when I ran into a restore failure reported by the log shipping restore job. A snippet of the error message is shown below:

*** Error: Could not apply log backup file ‘<backup file name>’ to secondary database ‘<database name>’.(Microsoft.SqlServer.Management.LogShipping) ***
*** Error: The operation cannot be performed on a database with database snapshots or active DBCC replicas.

The above error is reported as Error #5094. The error message is shown in bold above. Now this error occurred because I had created a database snapshot on the log shopped secondary database which was operating in standby (warm standby) mode. In such an event, you can only perform a log shipping restore on the secondary server after the database snapshot is dropped.

This also applies to the active DBCC replicas as well. Which means a DBCC CHECK being executed on the standby database could also cause a log shipping restore to fail. This issue would never occur if the secondary database was in no recovery mode since a database snapshot cannot be created for this log shipping operating mode.

The Ring_Buffer_Exception reports the error as:


The idea of putting this blog post together was to ensure that you were aware of this behavior before you created database snapshots on your standby log shipped secondary databases for reporting purposes.


Get your log shipping restore to run faster

Recently I was working on a customer environment where the requirement was to use a log shipped secondary database for reporting purposes. The catch here was that the restore of all the transaction log backups needed to complete within a fixed time.

Right at the outset, I would like to point out that the restore of transaction logs are dependent on a number of parameters like disk subsystem performance, number of transactions present in the log backup, resource availability on the server where the restore is occurring. Considering that all the factors remain constant, there is a basic difference between a secondary log shipped database in No Recovery and in Standby mode. In Standby mode, a partial recovery is done with the help of a transaction undo file to get the database into a read-only state. This partial recovery operation and undo that occurs while performing the next log restore (with the use of the transaction undo file) requires time and resources and can slow down the time of restore for each transaction log backup that is restored on the secondary database, especially if there are resource contention issues on the server. In this blog post, I shall outline how you can workaround the same in case you have to meet strict restore time SLAs.

Continue reading